Why do outboard motors of the same power sometimes take different propeller sizes?
This is due to differences in lower unit gear ratios. Stock outboards are geared so that the propeller shaft turns at a slower speed than the RPM at the power head. This is usually expressed as a ratio such as 12:21 or 14:28, referring to the number of teeth in the drive gears. The lower the gear ratio, the larger the propeller that can be used and vice versa.